This page may be out of date - the last successful update was more than a day ago.
Track record
This page shows what Tidebook and common indicators said at past turning points, including misses. It is a record, not a forecast.
Every Tidebook state below was reconstructed in October 2026 using classifier v1.1. Tidebook did not publish these at the time. Event days were fixed by rule before the results were seen: the highest or lowest daily close in a stated window.
Terms. MVRV compares BTC's market cap to its realized cap (the value of every coin priced at when it last moved on-chain). Net exchange flow is inflow minus outflow: positive means more BTC moved onto exchanges than off them, negative means the reverse. The exchange reserve is the BTC held in known exchange wallets. The Puell multiple compares the value of newly issued BTC with its own 365-day average. Fear and Greed is a market-mood index built from volatility, momentum, social volume and surveys. A zone is the range where a textbook reading applies. A percentile is the share of earlier days with a lower value.
The six turning points
For comparison, across all days since 2013 the median change in BTC was +8.0% over 90 days and +26.8% over 180 days.
2017 top
16 Dec 2017. BTC closed at $19,641, the highest close in December 2017.
Tidebook's state that day: not computed. Tidebook's classifier history starts on 11 Aug 2020.
- MVRV 4.43: in the zone for above 3.5.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 104,000 BTC in: in the zone for coins moving to exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: up 15.14%: in the zone for a rising reserve.
- Fear and Greed: not available before 1 Feb 2018.
- Puell multiple 6.35: in the zone for above 4.
What followed: BTC -57.3% after 90 days and -66.2% after 180 days. Largest drop within 90 days: -65.1%.
2018 bottom
15 Dec 2018. BTC closed at $3,185, the lowest close in December 2018.
Tidebook's state that day: not computed. Tidebook's classifier history starts on 11 Aug 2020.
- MVRV 0.69: in the zone for below 1.0.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 167,100 BTC in: in the zone for coins moving to exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: up 9.47%: in the zone for a rising reserve.
- Fear and Greed: 11: in the zone for extreme fear.
- Puell multiple 0.39: in the zone for below 0.5.
What followed: BTC +22.5% after 90 days and +158.5% after 180 days. The price did not close below that day's close in the next 90 days.
April 2021 top
13 Apr 2021. BTC closed at $63,446, the highest close in April 2021.
Tidebook's state that day (reconstructed): Stretched valuation, coins leaving exchanges. That period began 4 Apr 2021 and could be known from 6 Apr 2021.
MVRV 3.43, percentile 90.8 of its history to date. The stretched cut-off is MVRV 2.38 (the 75th percentile).
- MVRV 3.43: not in either zone.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 38,900 BTC out: in the zone for coins leaving exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: up 5.05%: in the zone for a rising reserve.
- Fear and Greed: 74: not in either zone.
- Puell multiple 2.70: not in either zone.
What followed: BTC -47.8% after 90 days and -13.8% after 180 days. Largest drop within 90 days: -50.1%.
November 2021 top
8 Nov 2021. BTC closed at $67,542, the highest close in November 2021.
Tidebook's state that day (reconstructed): Stretched valuation, coins leaving exchanges. That period began 24 Oct 2021 and could be known from 26 Oct 2021.
MVRV 2.85, percentile 83.3 of its history to date. The stretched cut-off is MVRV 2.41 (the 75th percentile).
- MVRV 2.85: not in either zone.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 35,900 BTC out: in the zone for coins leaving exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: down 3.61%: in the zone for a falling reserve.
- Fear and Greed: 75: not in either zone.
- Puell multiple 1.47: not in either zone.
What followed: BTC -37.3% after 90 days and -47.4% after 180 days. Largest drop within 90 days: -48.2%.
2022 bottom
9 Nov 2022. BTC closed at $15,758, the lowest close from 1 November to 31 December 2022.
Tidebook's state that day (reconstructed): Below fair value, coins leaving exchanges. That period began 8 Nov 2022 and could be known from 10 Nov 2022. That was after this day, so Tidebook could not have shown it then.
MVRV 0.75, percentile 2.4 of its history to date. The stretched cut-off is MVRV 2.32 (the 75th percentile).
- MVRV 0.75: in the zone for below 1.0.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 27,100 BTC out: in the zone for coins leaving exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: down 0.98%: not in either zone.
- Fear and Greed: 29: not in either zone.
- Puell multiple 0.48: in the zone for below 0.5.
What followed: BTC +47.6% after 90 days and +76.0% after 180 days. The price did not close below that day's close in the next 90 days.
2025 top
6 Oct 2025. BTC closed at $124,824, the highest close of 2025.
Tidebook's state that day (reconstructed): Mid-range valuation, coins leaving exchanges. That period began 3 Sep 2025 and could be known from 5 Sep 2025. The raw reading that day was Stretched valuation, coins leaving exchanges; a change needs 3 days in a row.
MVRV 2.29, percentile 75.9 of its history to date. The stretched cut-off is MVRV 2.27 (the 75th percentile).
- MVRV 2.29: not in either zone.
- Net exchange flow, 30 days: 82,700 BTC out: in the zone for coins leaving exchanges.
- Exchange reserve, 90 days: down 1.97%: not in either zone.
- Fear and Greed: 71: not in either zone.
- Puell multiple 1.07: not in either zone.
What followed: BTC -26.8% after 90 days and -46.1% after 180 days. Largest drop within 90 days: -32.1%.
Hits and misses, plainly
- Valuation band at the three tops since 2020: stretched and confirmed on the day in April 2021 and November 2021, not in October 2025.
- October 2025 was a miss. On 6 Oct 2025 MVRV was 2.29, 0.02 above the stretched cut-off of 2.27, but a change needs 3 days in a row. The confirmed state stayed mid-range valuation from 3 Sep to 14 Nov 2025 (72 days). Tidebook keeps classifier v1.1 and does not change thresholds after seeing a result.
- The flow half of the label read coins leaving exchanges at all three tops since 2020.
- At the November 2022 bottom the label read below fair value, but could only be known from 10 Nov 2022, the day after the low.
The two tests
Both tests were written down and signed before the results were seen (17 Oct 2026) and each was run once (17 Oct 2026). Some results can look strong by chance when many are tested. All results are listed and none is singled out.
Do Tidebook's states differ from an ordinary day?
All days since 2020: median 90-day change +4.8%.
Tidebook's states against an ordinary day, 90 days later| State | Result |
|---|
| Below fair value, coins leaving exchanges | 3 of 9 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
| Below fair value, coins moving to exchanges | 6 of 10 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
| Mid-range valuation, coins leaving exchanges | 14 of 25 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
| Mid-range valuation, coins moving to exchanges | 10 of 21 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
| Stretched valuation, coins leaving exchanges | 6 of 13 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
| Stretched valuation, coins moving to exchanges | 3 of 9 periods above the all-days median since 2020. No clear difference |
|---|
Did the textbook readings hold?
A case held when BTC's change over the next 90 days was on the textbook side of the all-days median: +8.0% since 2013 (+3.0% since 2018 for Fear and Greed).
Textbook readings, record since the year shown| Reading | Result |
|---|
| MVRV, above 3.5 | Went the other way in 5 of 7 cases since 2013. |
|---|
| MVRV, below 1.0 | Held in 1 of 7 cases since 2013. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
| Net exchange flow, coins leaving exchanges | Held in 24 of 42 cases since 2013. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
| Net exchange flow, coins moving to exchanges | Held in 18 of 38 cases since 2013. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
| Exchange reserve, a falling reserve | Held in 13 of 22 cases since 2013. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
| Exchange reserve, a rising reserve | Went the other way in 11 of 18 cases since 2013. |
|---|
| Fear and Greed, extreme fear | Held in 11 of 26 cases since 2018. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
| Fear and Greed, extreme greed | Went the other way in 9 of 13 cases since 2018. |
|---|
| Puell multiple, above 4 | Only 4 cases since 2013. Too few to judge. |
|---|
| Puell multiple, below 0.5 | Held in 5 of 13 cases since 2013. Not clearly different from chance. |
|---|
Some on-chain metrics provided by Coin Metrics Community Network Data, licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Fear & Greed Index data via alternative.me.